In the icy waters of a Siberian harbour, the Christophe de Margerie, a Russian ship with an uncommon French identify, was prepared for loading. The world’s first ice-breaking fuel tanker had been designed for a really particular objective: opening up Russia’s Arctic transport routes in direction of Europe and Asia through the winter months.
It was December 2017, and the temperatures had plunged to -27C, however the politicians and oil executives gathered in Sabetta, on the Yamal peninsula, have been jubilant. Vladimir Putin had flown in for the occasion. On the president’s sign, fuel started to pump into the tanker.
“That is most likely the most important step within the improvement of the Arctic,” Putin declared.
As they watched, the onlookers can have seen one other of the ship’s distinguishing options: its prow was painted with an enormous white moustache.
The whiskers – and the identify – have been a tribute to the previous boss of the French oil main Whole. Generally known as “large moustache” for his luxuriant facial hair, De Margerie had spent years flying between Paris and Moscow, establishing a $27bn (£22bn) partnership with Novatek, Russia’s largest non-public fuel group, and China’s state oil firm, to remodel a distant wilderness with an enormous untapped fuel subject right into a busy industrial hub.
Sabetta now has a port, an airport, a railway station, an influence plant and a facility for condensing methane into its liquid kind. The liquid pure fuel (LNG) is then exported by sea. However De Margerie was not there for the tanker’s inauguration. He had been killed in an accident three years earlier, when his non-public airplane collided with a snow plough at Moscow airport.
Doing enterprise in Russia comes with dangers, however the rewards could be tempting. Within the 5 years since 2017, Whole (or TotalEnergies as it’s now identified) has collected almost $1.8bn (£1.48bn) in dividends from its investments with Novatek, and its Yamal LNG three way partnership; $750m of that within the final 12 months, in keeping with the corporate’s filings. Advisers to the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, have described the earnings as “blood cash”.
Within the days that adopted Russia’s assault on Ukraine, the French president, Emmanuel Macron, acted as an middleman, sustaining a dialogue with Putin earlier than ultimately distancing himself. Whole took an analogous strategy: whereas BP and Shell introduced an intention to chop ties inside days of the 24 February invasion, and Norway’s Equinor has accomplished its exit, Whole continued working with Novatek.
On Friday final week, it modified tack. Whole wrote off the worth of its near-20% stake in Novatek and its two representatives on the board resigned with speedy impact.
The timing appeared shocking. “The important thing questions from at this time’s launch is why now and never earlier,” one analyst advised Reuters.
The Guardian can reveal the Whole press launch got here hours earlier than a 5pm deadline for a response to a letter, despatched by this newspaper, elevating questions on Yamal LNG’s ties to the Kremlin.
Whole mentioned there was no hyperlink between the deadline and the announcement. It mentioned it had already written down the worth of its Russian investments by billions of {dollars} and give up one other three way partnership with Novatek. A spokesperson mentioned the choice was “a brand new logical step, according to our ideas of conduct of gradual withdrawing from our Russian property”.
Our investigation shines a light-weight on how two members of Putin’s internal circle, Gennady Timchenko and Peter Kolbin, appeared to play a job in bringing Novatek, Russia’s largest non-public fuel firm, below Kremlin management, making enormous earnings within the course of.
A few of this story has been advised earlier than however some necessary particulars are new. Many of those occasions passed off whereas Novatek was listed on the London Inventory Alternate, the place its shares have been owned by blue chip funds on behalf of British savers. Seen by way of the lens of current occasions, it’s a reminder of the issues of doing enterprise below the Putin regime.
Kolbin was a childhood buddy of Putin’s and is assumed to have died in 2018. He’s described by the UK authorities as Putin’s “alleged enterprise affiliate” and extensively claimed as having been a purse-holder for the Russian president. We will reveal an offshore firm of which he was a beneficiary seems to have booked greater than $400m in earnings from promoting a stake in Yamal LNG.
The transaction was recorded in firm filings as having taken place in 2011. The identical 12 months Whole invested $4bn in Novatek and a separate, undisclosed quantity within the Yamal LNG enterprise. Whole mentioned it purchased its share in Yamal from Novatek.
By piecing collectively data from offshore leaks – together with the Panama Papers, company and transport registries in Cyprus and Russia, and paperwork supplied by a supply to the File Middle, an investigations unit funded by the exiled oil boss Mikhail Khodorkovsky – we now have traced a community of secretive offshore corporations apparently utilized by Kolbin and Timchenko to handle their investments in Yamal.
That community seems to attach Timchenko to cash paid for constructing one among Putin’s costliest playthings – a $100m superyacht known as the Sleek.
In a press release, Whole mentioned: “Provided that TotalEnergies’ investments in Novatek and Yamal LNG have been carried out publicly, at market worth, with respectable and rightful shareholders who had precise enterprise actions and who weren’t topic to any sanctions, TotalEnergies categorically rejects all of the unfounded and ludicrous allegations about being concerned, in any approach, in alleged transactions destined to complement Vladimir Putin or his internal circle.”
It mentioned Novatek and its companions have been in a position to increase multibillion-dollar worldwide financing for the Yamal LNG undertaking after thorough due diligence of reputed worldwide monetary establishments.
Novatek mentioned it follows stringent company governance requirements, and its monetary statements are verified by exterior auditors and its board of administrators, who embrace unbiased members of the worldwide enterprise group. It mentioned transactions on the firm have been all the time made on market phrases and helpful to all shareholders, including: “Novatek is just not conscious of, and doesn’t touch upon, actions by individuals who aren’t concerned within the firm administration in addition to transactions which can be outdoors of the corporate’s actions.”
A spokesperson for Putin didn’t reply to a request for remark. Timchenko and Kolbin’s household didn’t reply to emails.
Originally found within the Nineteen Seventies, the South Tambey fuel subject lies beneath the permafrost of the distant Yamal peninsula, the place the snowy plains present an important habitat for reindeer, polar bears and wild birds.
Within the post-Soviet privatisation drive of the mid-Nineties, a former KGB colonel, Nikolai Bogachev, noticed the chance and bought the South Tambey licence. He ultimately partnered with Novatek.
Novatek’s founder is Leonid Mikhelson, a 67-year-old engineer who began out as a development foreman earlier than going into enterprise.
Vladimir Milov, a former deputy power minister below Putin, now an opposition campaigner, holds him within the highest regard. “He’s able to large-scale visionary stuff and getting issues carried out. Within the fuel trade I’ve by no means seen a high-level skilled like this, he’s primary.”
In quest of capital to start drilling, Mikhelson approached Whole. In the summertime of 2004, he struck an settlement to promote 1 / 4 of Novatek’s shares to the French firm.
However the transaction bumped into political opposition, and Russia’s Federal Antimonopoly Service refused to provide approval.
So Novatek turned to the London Inventory Alternate, elevating $880m. The 2005 itemizing seems to have been a set off for a collection of offers. It was additionally a interval throughout which the South Tambey licence modified arms a number of instances.
Bogachev quickly discovered himself below what he believed was authorities strain to promote his 74.9% in Yamal LNG, integrated by him to carry the licence, after Gazprombank, a subsidiary of the state-owned fuel large Gazprom, launched a authorized grievance.
Bogachev’s son Victor, who was despatched to dwell within the US, alleged in a 2017 interview that his father had been topic to a marketing campaign of intimidation.
“There have been raids on his workplace with weapons looking for data. He had three automobiles following him always. Once we have been in his workplace he would flip up the TV noise loud and inform us in whispers what’s the improvement. It was intense. Fortuitously, due to his connections, they didn’t go after him in a approach that might be life threatening.”
Bogachev gained the authorized case on enchantment however agreed to promote his share in Yamal LNG to a non-public firm. Gazprom then set its sights on Novatek, buying a piece of its shares and gaining two boardroom seats.
Mikhelson wanted a method. With out political safety, Novatek’s founder could have confronted comparable pressures to Bogachev. “Novatek couldn’t have survived as an unbiased producer if it didn’t permit folks from Putin’s internal circle to come back in and turn into shareholders,” Milov claimed. “What Mikhelson did is the smoothest integration with the Kremlin’s folks. Not a hostile takeover. He purchased himself the flexibility to implement his imaginative and prescient.”
Mikhelson didn’t reply to a separate request for remark.
It was at this level that Timchenko grew to become a shareholder in Novatek, buying a 5% stake in 2008 by way of his conglomerate, Volga Group. The 70-year-old St Petersberg oil dealer has identified Putin for the reason that Nineties and the pair rose up the business and political ranks in tandem. They share a ardour for judo, ice hockey – and canine. Timchenko as soon as advised an interviewer his household pet, Rommie, was the daughter of Putin’s black labrador Connie. She spent her first weeks as a pet residing in one of many presidential palaces.
Additionally in 2008, Timchenko acquired the 74.9% share of Yamal LNG that Bogachev had relinquished. The transaction passed off offshore, in Cyprus, the place there isn’t a obligation to declare who finally owns an organization. The Cyprus-registered entities Aldi Buying and selling Ltd and Orsel Consultants Ltd purchased 25% every, whereas Innecto Ventures Ltd purchased 24.9%. Leaked paperwork join all three to Timchenko, and he would later declare a connection.
In April 2009, one other Cyprus firm, Varix Enterprises, acquired 25.1% of Yamal from Gazprombank, in keeping with press experiences. It was not till the next 12 months that the id of the brand new proprietor of Yamal emerged: Interfax information company named the customer as Kolbin.
It has since emerged that Kolbin and Putin grew up collectively, within the village of Imenitsy, close to the Estonian border. Their fathers have been associates and as youngsters they brawled with boys from a neighbouring village. Their grownup lives would diverge, with Kolbin ultimately working in a Soviet butcher’s store, whereas Putin joined the KGB. Nevertheless, the president by no means forgot his previous buddy: he despatched Kolbin a birthday letter shortly after turning into head of state.
“Kolbin is usually thought-about a window-dressing consultant of Putin,” Milov mentioned. “Timchenko was all the time personally very concerned in enterprise and choices. Kolbin was clearly representing another person.”
In Could 2009, Volga Group introduced it had elevated its stake in Novatek, and Timchenko had been made a director. As a part of the deal, Novatek would purchase a 51% share of Yamal LNG from Volga and related corporations.
Between them, Timchenko and state-owned Gazprom now owned extra of Novatek than Mikhelson and his administration group. Reporting the deal, the monetary newspaper Kommersant declared: “Novatek misplaced its independence.”
The historian and writer Anne Applebaum mentioned management of strategically necessary corporations is central to how Putin governs. “Putin’s grip on energy in Russia may be very intently associated to his assault on the oligarchs and his makes an attempt to deliver them below management. The aim of it was to guarantee that all people carried out enterprise in Russia solely together with his permission.”
Until this 12 months, most of Russia’s fuel was transported by way of pipelines to Europe. However the move has largely stopped because the Kremlin pressures western governments over the conflict towards Ukraine. For Putin, exporting fuel by sea in ultra-chilled LNG kind to still-friendly buying and selling companions, reminiscent of China and India, is now a prime precedence.
Yamal’s significance is just not solely business. “One in every of Putin’s ambitions was to re-establish Russian management over the Arctic coast,” mentioned Mikhail Krutikhin, a associate on the consultancy RusEnergy. Moscow’s navy presence within the area was weakened by the autumn of the Soviet Union, and Putin was satisfied commerce might assist reverse that. “This was a undertaking that had a really fascinating political which means,” Krutikhin mentioned.
In 2011, Whole was lastly allowed on to Novatek’s shareholder register. On 2 March that 12 months, it acquired a 14.1% chunk of Novatek for $4bn, which Whole says it purchased from Mikhelson and Timchenko. It additionally acquired a direct 20% stake in Yamal LNG from Novatek for an undisclosed sum.
Whole mentioned it purchased the Yamal shares from Novatek “and its 100%-owned affiliate” and that “every time, Whole paid the due quantities on to the respective house owners or by way of corporations primarily based throughout the European Union”.
Days later, Kolbin apparently cashed in. On 14 March, firm accounts present Varix offered its shares in Yamal for $526m, netting an estimated $416m revenue. That September, Timchenko offered up, too. Innecto’s remaining 23.9% went for $450m, in keeping with firm filings.
Including up the assorted transactions, Timchenko and Kolbin seem to have offered Yamal for £1.6bn. They acquired the entire firm in 2008, offered a few of it in 2009, and the remainder in 2011. As a result of the accounts declaring the offers have been solely filed in 2014, when the Cyprus corporations have been being liquidated, the earnings remained hidden from public view for years. The filings don’t identify the customer.
With marble bogs and tooled leather-based furnishings, a helipad and a 15-metre indoor pool that may be lined to make a dance flooring, the Sleek superyacht prices greater than $5m a 12 months to keep up. In June, the US Treasury recognized the yacht as “property by which President Vladimir Putin has an curiosity”, and which he had used for “quite a few” journeys. Putin has not commented on these allegations.
Leaked paperwork and papers from a court docket dispute unearthed by the Finnish broadcaster Yle counsel the no-expense-spared development was funded at the least partly by a British Virgin Islands firm known as Olneil Belongings Corp. Till 2019, Olneil was named on the Lloyds transport register because the proprietor of the Sleek. Olneil seems to have been a part of Timchenko and Kolbin’s offshore construction. It was finally managed by way of the identical Panama firm, a nominee shareholder known as Mishositos SA. From 2020, the Sleek was moved to the Russian transport registry, the place it was owned by a Russian firm, which finally belonged to a British Virgin Islands firm. That BVI firm, Navolution Ventures Ltd, seems to have been managed by Timchenko, offshore paperwork counsel.
Navolution is called as a “associated occasion” in accounts filed by a Timchenko Cyprus firm, Innecto. The submitting offers a transparent definition for the time period: “Associated events are corporations that are topic to frequent management”.
An bill dated 29 June 2011, addressed to Olneil and issued by the Maritime Authority of the Cayman Islands, exhibits one of many registry’s surveyors travelled to Germany for a “assembly to debate Undertaking Sleek”. Olneil was charged for the surveyor’s lodging, journey, communications and a €60 “every day allowance”.
In September 2011, an engineering firm in Florida had despatched one other bill to Olneil, for the set up of a “two-fin stabiliser system”, costing €123,620.
There isn’t any proof the yacht was funded by cash made on the Yamal deal. Timchenko is price an estimated $13bn and will have sourced the money from different investments.
In 2013, Timchenko acquired France’s highest order of advantage, the Légion d’honneur, from François Hollande. Regardless of being blacklisted by the US a 12 months later, after Russia’s annexation of Crimea, the EU didn’t impose sanctions on him till February this 12 months. Shortly after, he resigned from the board of Novatek.
Europe has walked the tightrope of opposing the conflict, whereas making certain some Russian fuel retains flowing. Mikhelson, who stays the chair of Novatek, has had sanctions imposed by Canada and the UK, who don’t depend on Russian fuel, however not by the EU or the US. Brussels has not commented on the matter.
Whole’s Russian withdrawal remains to be solely partial. It’s retaining the shares in Yamal LNG and one other promising three way partnership with Novatek, Arctic LNG 2. In a press release, Whole indicated it might proceed to just accept dividends in the event that they have been paid. A spokesperson mentioned: “EU authorities have requested TotalEnergies to contribute towards securing Europe’s fuel provide from the Yamal LNG plant throughout the framework of long-term contracts that the corporate should honour so long as Europe’s governments don’t take sanctions on Russian LNG.”
In the meantime, the Christophe de Margerie sails on. Since October, a vessel tracker exhibits it has made two journeys to LNG terminals in Spain, and is now crossing the Arctic on its approach again to Siberia.